Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Philosophy and Culture
Reference:

Chernovitskaya Yu.V. Transformation of the Concept of Genocide in Modern Society

Abstract: In her article Chernovitskaya analyzes the growth of the political, social, economic and other genocide practices in the world, their acceptability and emergence of new violent practices which underlines the conceptual crisis of the term 'genocide', its controversial and contradictory nature. This emphasizes the need for creating an objective criterion for defining genocide. Chernovitskaya underlines how important it is to move from the principle of political premeditation in determining genocide to the principle of the system regularities, according to which the political, economic and social changes combined with the negligence of the ruling regime lead to massive destruction of the group, despite the fact that the destruction of the group is not directly intended. At the same time, at the present stage of developmet of human society the most dangerous feature is becoming the tendency towards transformation of direct genocide into indirect kind of genocide. This tendency is manifested in delibirate economic interventions aimed at changing the cultural and historical environment, in biological interventions aimed at changing the natural environment, and etc. Widespread modern technology does not only brings a person beyond his physical abilities, but also reduces the responsibility of management systems and distorts the concept of responsibility leading to gradual weakening of personal moral responsibility.


Keywords:

directed change, genocide, tendency towards transformation, intention, system regularities, indirect genocide, violent practices, technologies, moral responsibility, conceptual crisis


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article


References
1. Konventsiya o preduprezhdenii prestupleniya genotsida i nakazaniya za nego ot 9 dekabrya 1948 g. // Mezhdunarodnoe pravo v dokumentakh / Sostavitel' N.T.Blatova, G.M.Melkov. M.: Profobrazovanie, 2003. 879 s.
2. Sm.: Kochoi S. Genotsid: ponyatie, otvetstvennost', praktika // Ugolovnoe pravo. 2001. ¹ 2. S. 95-97.
3. Vartanyan V.M. Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost' za genotsid. Avtoref... diss... k.yu.n. Stavropol', 2000. 27 s.
4. Sm. Traynin A.N. Izbrannye proizvedeniya. Zashchita mira i ugolovnyy zakon. M.: Nauka, 1969. 454 s.
5. Ternon Iv. Razmyshleniya o genotside. [Elektronnyy resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa www.hrights.ru (data obrashcheniya 13.02.2014)
6. Shatalov A.T., Myandina G.I. Evgenika v kontekste sovremennykh dostizheniy genetiki cheloveka // Evgenika v diskurse global'nykh problem sovremennosti / Otv. red. Yu.V.Khen. M.: Kanon+, 2005. S. 218-239.
7. Maylenova F.G. Vozmozhnosti modifikatsii prirody cheloveka segodnya // Bioetika i gumanitarnaya ekspertiza. Vyp. 2. M.: IF RAN, 2008. S. 83-94.
8. Vartanyan V.M. Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost' za genotsid. Dis. … kand. yurid. nauk. Stavropol', 2000. 166 s.
9. Madievskiy S. Pochemu Kholokost? // Novyy mir. ¹ 9. 1998. S. 219-227.
10. Zubets O.P. Ot diskussii o lzhi k molchaniyu o Kholokoste // Postigaya dobro: sbornik statey. K 60-letiyu Rubena Grantovicha Apresyana. M.: Al'fa-M, 2013. S. 290-310.
11. Panarin A.S. Strategicheskaya nestabil'nost' v KhKhI veke. M.: Algoritm, 2003. 560 s.
12. Kochetov E.G. Globalistika kak geoekonomika, kak real'nost', kak mirozdanie… M.: OAO Izdatel'skaya gruppa «PROGRESS», 2001. 704 s.
13. Kochetov E.G. Globalistika: Teoriya, metodologiya, praktika. M.: Izdatel'stvo NORMA, 2002. 647 s.
14. Sychev A.A. Eticheskie izmereniya bioraznoobraziya // Postigaya dobro: sbornik statey. K 60-letiyu Rubena Grantovicha Apresyana. M.: Al'fa-M, 2013. S. 385-401.
15. Panarin A.S. Iskushenie globalizmom. M., 2002. 415 s.
16. Mill J.St. The philosophy of John Stuart Mill. N.Y., 1961. P. 198. Tsit. po: Tishchenko P.D. Ugroza mnozhestvennosti i ideya gumanitarnoy ekspertizy // Bioetika i gumanitarnaya ekspertiza. Vyp. 2. M.: IF RAN, 2008. S. 102-128.
17. Tishchenko P.D. Ugroza mnozhestvennosti i ideya gumanitarnoy ekspertizy // Bioetika i gumanitarnaya ekspertiza. Vyp. 2. M.: IF RAN, 2008. S. 102-128.
18. Genotsid (entsiklopediya katastrof) / Pod red. Revyako T.I. Mn.: Literatura, 1996. 423 s.
19. Panarin A.S. Filosofiya politiki. M.: Novaya shkola, 1996. 424 s.
20. Merkulov I.P. Vzaimosvyaz' biologicheskoy i kul'turnoy evolyutsii // Biologiya i kul'tura. / Otv.red. Liseev I.K. M.: Kanon+, 2004. S. 288-317.
21. Liseev I.K. Predislovie // Evgenika v diskurse global'nykh problem sovremennosti / Otv.red. Khen Yu.V. M.: Kanon+, 2005. S. 3-6.
22. Jonas H. Philosophical Reflection on Experiments with Human Subjects // Experimentation with Human Subjects / Ed. By P.A.Freund, George Braziller Inc., 1970. P. 529. Tsit. po: Yudin B.G. Eticheskoe izmerenie sovremennoy nauki // Etika nauki. M.: IF RAN, 2007. S. 98-116.
23. Khen Yu.V. Tseli i sredstva evgeniki (eticheskiy i estestvennonauchnyy status distsipliny) // Filosofiya nauki. Vyp. 11: Etos nauki na rubezhe vekov. M.: IF RAN, 2005. S. 243-260.
24. Tishchenko P.D. Eticheskie problemy razvitiya biotekhnologiy // Bioetika i gumanitarnaya ekspertiza. Vyp. 2. M.: IF RAN, 2008. S. 55-82.
25. Emanuel', Iezekiil' Dzh. Eticheskaya i pravovaya storona provedeniya klinicheskikh issledovaniy (Ethical and regulatory aspects of clinical research): sbornik statey i kommentariev; per. s angl. pod. red. V. V. Vlasova. M.: Prakticheskaya meditsina, 2013. 493 s.
26. Sm.: Bromley Yu.V. Ocherki teorii etnosa. M.: Nauka, 1983. 418 s.
27. Kozlov V.I. Osnovnye problemy etnicheskoy ekologii // Sov.etnografiya. 1983. S. 3-16.
28. Markuze G. Eros i tsivilizatsiya. Odnomernyy chelovek: Issledovanie ideologii razvitogo industrial'nogo obshchestva / G. Markuze; Per. s angl., poslesl., primech. A.A. Yudina; Sost., predisl. V.Yu. Kuznetsova. M: OOO "Izdatel'stvo ACT", 2002. 526 s.
29. Gerasimova I.A. Etos nauki. Problema dobra i zla // Etos nauki. M.: Academia, 2008. S. 317-337.
30. Skolimowski H. Freedom, Responsibility and the Information Society. Vital Speeches 50, no. 16 (June I, 1984), p. 495. Tsit. po: Mitchem K. Chto takoe filosofiya tekhniki? M.: Aspekt Press, 1995. 149 s.
31. Delyagin M. Mesto Rossii v usloviyakh globalizatsii // Nash sovremennik. ¹ 7, 2001.
32. Nasilie: sotsio-politicheskiy analiz / A.V.Dmitriev, I.Yu.Zalysin. M.: ROSSPEN, 2000. 328 s.
33. Arendt Kh. Otvetstvennost' i suzhdenie. M.: Izd. Instituta Gaydara, 2013. 352 s.
34. Brossat A. Tsit. po Kotek Zh., Rigulo P. Vek lagerey: lishenie svobody, kontsentratsiya, unichtozhenie. Sto let zlodeyaniy. M.: Tekst, 2003. 687 s.
35. Bibler V.S. Perestroyka i nravstvennost' (materialy Kruglogo stola) // Vopr. filosofii. 1990. ¹ 7. S. 13-14.
36. Mitchem K. Chto takoe filosofiya tekhniki? M.: Aspekt Press, 1995. 149 s.